The similarities and differences of their system, compared with the classic bone age method of greulich and pyle in the 1950 radiographic atlas of skeletal development of the hand and wrist, are discussed, and, admittedly, the possible convenience of this cdrom alternate method is its selling point. Bone age assessment is frequently performed in pediatric patients to evalu ate growth and to diagnose and. Bone age assessment is a procedure frequently performed in pediatric patients to evaluate their growth disorder. Bone age was estimated for each individual using both gp and gg methods. Applicability of greulich and pyle skeletal age standards to indian children. Future studies should evaluate the results in a larger number of participants. Is the assessment of bone age by the greulich pyle method reliable at forensic age estimation for turkish children. Our aim is to assess its accuracy and to calculate the prediction intervals at 95%. Abstract bone age represents only one factor of the child development and needs to be included in the whole physical and biological context. Radiographic atlas of skeletal development of the hand and. Radiographic skeletal analysis of handwrist skeletal development is often used to infer chronological age based on direct comparison to standards such as the greulich and pyle atlas. Pdf hand mri and the greulichpyle atlas in skeletal age. The first section deals with patients prior to age of expected skeletal maturity and the second section for patients at or after the age of expected skeletal maturity.
Assessment of the accuracy of the greulich and pyle hand. This study aims to examine the applicability of the greulich and pyle atlas to a modern scottish greulich and pyle atlas to assess whether it is appropriate for forensic use as a method of age estimation when applied to a contemporary population. Lefthand radiographs of 679 children 375 boys ranging in age from 1 day to 18 years old were obtained for trauma in the period 20012009 and were evaluated for bone. The reliability of skeletal age determination by the. Pdf comparative study of greulich and pyle atlas and maturos 4. The skeletal age in months was greater than the chronological age in 77% of the children. This study assesses the value of the greulich and pyle method in determining the skeletal ages of healthy american children of european and african. Effect of knowledge of chronologic age on the variability of. Automatic determination of greulich and pyle bone age in.
Digital hand atlas and webbased bone age assessment. Discussion this project sought to test the greulich and pyle atlas method of age estimation on a modern scottish population. Tanner jm, whitehouse rh, cameron n et al 1975 assessment. Background bone age ba assessment is a routine procedure in paediatric radiology, for which the greulich and pyle gp atlas is mostly used. To our knowledge, the greulich and pyle standards have not been reassessed for both black and white children. Mean differences between chronological age and estimated age months for male lefthand images. Automatic determination of greulich and pyle bone age in healthy dutch. Comparing these chosen standards with hundreds of normal children of similar chronological age, they were then able to calculate standard. Pediatricians have relied on methods for determining skeletal maturation for 75 years. A simple method commonly used in bone age assessment is atlas matching by a radiological examination of a lefthand radiograph against a small reference set of greulich pyle atlas patterns of normal standards. A difference between estimated age and chronological age of this magnitude means that in a forensic situation, the estimated age assigned through the use of the greulich and pyle atlas alone could result in a 3. Quality of the studies was assessed using the national institute for health and care excellence tool.
A radiographic atlas and digital bone age companion. Studies in use of greulihc greulich pyle skeletal age method to assess criminal liability. Greulich and pyle selected representative radiographs to correspond with each chronological age represented in the atlas. The greulich and pyle skeletal age atlas was derived from white children of upper socioeconomic level during the 1930s. Tannerwhitehouse atlas involves the scoring of each carpal bone, the radius and ulna leading to a total score, from which age can be estimated 2. A digital atlas of skeletal maturity by vicente gilsanz. Bone age is commonly assessed by one of two main methods. Skeletal maturity of youths 1217 years, united states. The standards established by greulich and pyle, undoubtedly the most popular method, consist of two series of standard plates obtained from handwrist radiographs of white, upper middleclass boys and girls en. New technology for bone age determination includes computerautomated readings and assessments obtained from alternative imaging modalities. Automatic determination of greulich and pyle bone age in healthy. Zafar et al 12 who compared bone and chronological ages at the agha khan university hospital, karachi also found that the mean differences between the ages was less in females as compared to males in children of.
This study corroborates a study done in 1993, 34 years after the work of greulich and pyle on black and white children in the same geographic area. Reproducibility of bone ages when performed by radiology registrars. Results seven subjects showed a deviation between manual. When groups are broken down into 5year cohorts, greulich and pyle atlas standard deviation is noticeably smaller in the 0 to 5year greulich and pyle atlas groups for both sexes. Is greulich and pyle standards of skeletal maturation. Greulich and pyle atlas presents a single standardized image for a range of ages of each gender 1. Automatic determination of greulich and pyle bone age in healthy dutch children article pdf available in pediatric radiology 396. All the xrays were acquired using either qrad shimadzu medical systems, japan or otc 12s del medical systems, usa. This study examines the accuracy of the pyle and hoerr radiographic atlas technique in join for free. Hand bone age a digital atlas of skeletal maturity.
The reliability of the greulich and pyle atlas when applied to a modern scottish population. Between 12 and 15 years the bone age with the mt program is closer to the. There is rater variability, but the advent of automatic ba determination eliminates this. Although an old text, which has been reprinted multiple times over the intervening years, many departments of radiology around the world still rely on tattered old copies of this slim volume. The age of healthy adolescents could be correctly estimated by expert readers within 2 sd by hand mri and the greulich pyle atlas, with high agreement. However, when using only 1 sd, bone ages tend to be estimated as older than the chronologic ages. Vicente gilsanz osman ratib hand bone age a digital atlas of skeletal maturity with 88 figures atlas greulich y pyle. The gilsanz and ratib digital atlas takes advantage of digital imaging and provides a more effective and objective approach to assessment of skeletal maturity. In addition, new nonclinical bone age applications are evolving, particularly. The skeletal age of a test population is estimated by comparison with. Applicability of the greulich and pyle skeletal age. Skeletal age determinations in children of european and.
A systematic search of the medline, embase and cochrane databases was conducted. Rezwana begum mohammed 1, dola srinivasa rao 2, alampur srinivas goud 3, s sailaja 4, anshuj ajay rao thetay 5, meera gopalakrishnan 6 1 department of oral medicine and radiology, gitam dental college and hospital, visakhapatnam, andhra pradesh, india 2 department of. Hand mri and the greulichpyle atlas in skeletal age. We searched medline using keywords greulich and pyle or greulich pyle, bone age assessment or bone age determination and left hand and refined the search to include articles in english published between 1st january 1959 and 15th february 2017. Skeletal age estimation as a means of assessing development and skeletal maturation in children and adolescents is of great importance for clinical and forensic purposes. Bhand mri and the greulich pyle atlas in skeletal age estimation in adolescents,received a great deal of attention. Greulich pyle method gp method is a method of bone age determination based on the comparison of. Determination of skeletal age in nigerian children. Greulich and pyle atlas definition of greulich and pyle.
Applicability of greulich and pyle method for age assessment in forensic practice on an italian sample. Other bone age and height prediction methods commonly in use are. In the past, determination of bone maturity relied on visual evaluation of skeletal development in the hand and wrist, most commonly using the greulich and pyle atlas. Skeletal age sa of a test population can be estimated by comparing with established standards of greulich and pyle gp. Pdf dembetembe morris 2012 greulich pyle age estimation. Nowaday age determination has gained importance for various forensic and legal reasons. Objective the greulich and pyle gp atlas is one of the most frequently used methods of bone age ba estimation. Greulich and pyle 1 address the issue of differen tial.
Greulich and pyle s radiographic atlas of skeletal development of the hand and wrist. The full text of this article is available in pdf format. Pdf automatic determination of greulich and pyle bone. The differences between chronological age and estimated age were broken grwulich further into year cohorts for each sex table 5. Greulich and pyle atlas collection of plates, illustrations, text, and xrays providing data on bone age. Dembetembe morris 2012 greulich pyle age estimation in africans. Abstractage estimation of living individuals is topical, and is particularly important globally, owing to increasing migration of undocumented individuals.
1116 1540 1349 1129 268 387 105 30 431 1659 84 1405 68 624 676 424 1549 1244 672 245 1431 397 1128 1352 536 1339 1038 152 453 232 303 273